When deciding which operating system (OS)/computer to buy, the following factors (though non-exhaustive) have to be taken into consideration:
This was once the key determinant of the present debate.
Many would choose Apple Mac because the MacOS is superior in many ways, and more user-friendly. However, Microsoft has made significant improvements with Windows 10 OS, which has now become very user-friendly. For instance, Windows 10 comes bundled with the extremely intuitive and useful Timeline feature – something that is not available on the MacOS.
In the past, most law firms would choose Windows due to their heavy reliance on certain software applications which are only available on the Windows platform. For example, Microsoft Office used to operate more efficiently on Windows than on the Mac platform. This is no longer so as Microsoft now operates well on both operating systems.
The choice of OS is also less important these days because most small firm lawyers rely on software that are interoperable, i.e. the same software can be found on both Mac or Windows. Many of these softwares are also cloud-based and/or browser-based, which means you can use them regardless of the OS you are using. This includes other less widely used OS such as Chromium, Linux, and even the mobile OSes: iOS and Android.
Choose models, not brands. Most established business laptop brands have a particular series/model that is well known for reliability (e.g. ThinkPad series for Lenovo, Portege series for Toshiba etc.). Even within the same series, there are some models which are more well-built than the others (e.g. the ThinkPad X series will most likely last longer than the ThinkPad E series due to the way the former model is built). The same applies for the Mac series.
Purchase one with same-business-day on-site service, if possible (e.g. if you travel a lot, ThinkPad’s worldwide warranty can come in very handy).
– If more ports are required (VGA, Smart Card readers – although you might want to decide whether these ports are still necessary), Windows would be a better option due to the wider choices available in the market. Apple Mac on the other hand are not equipped with ports, and dongles have to be purchased in place of ports.
– Keyboards are often overlooked. As lawyers spend a lot of time typing, keyboards have to be ergonomical for comfort and efficiency. For instance, users may not like the MacBook’s “Butterfly keyboard” as typing on the keyboard may seem similar to tapping on a flat surface. Another option would be to purchase a separate keyboard to replace the “Butterfly keyboard”.
– MacBooks generally have decent battery life for the first few years, but the batteries are non-removable and hence irreplaceable. Therefore, the better choice would be Windows which allow batteries to be replaced. This is of paramount importance if lawyers often work remotely.
Now that we have covered the general factors, we take a deeper look into what a lawyer should consider for the different operating systems.
The resolution of the perennial debate on the use of the quintessential windows computer versus the Mac for work ultimately boils down to this: individual user experience.
What has not been typically covered is how the Mac can be used to suit your legal needs.
For example, Mac’s native PDF reader, presents a host of advantages that not many know of.
Litigation lawyers know and understand the pain of putting together the different bundles of documents and authorities. Preview offers an easy solution. In your Finder window, simply number off your files that are to be added to the bundle in order of appearance, sort the files by name, and right click for them to be opened in Preview. The files will automatically be opened in order on Preview. Simply select all pages in the side pane on Preview, and print all as a PDF from there.
Sometimes, we require only certain extracts of documents/scans to be included in a research piece. Simply open the sidebar navigation pane in preview, and drag out the relevant pages into a new extract.
Sometimes when photographs of documents such as receipts are scanned, they are difficult to read. Preview has an in-built function allowing for image-editing such as increasing brightness etc. which would help document readability. Simply open the image file in Preview, and select Tools -> Adjust colour.
The Mac OS also allows you to organise your workspace by categorising and organising them at the following levels:
a. Mission Control (keyboard shortcut: F3): displays all your active windows in a single desktop screen.
b. App Expose: displays all your active windows of the same application (e.g. this view would display all your active Microsoft word documents, but not the browser tabs open in the same desktop.)
MacOS have always been well-known for its security systems. While Windows computers often suffer from virus attacks and ransomware, Mac computers rarely have this problem. Perhaps due to the fact that there are many more Windows computers in the world, hackers have more incentives to create viruses for Windows computers (as compared to viruses for the other OSes).
For lawyers, this means your documents and sensitive information will be more secure as compared to a normal Windows computer. This would be especially important for lawyers who receive many emails from different parties. Sometimes all it takes is one rogue email containing a link to a malicious website to cause the damage.
In the past, Mac had many features which Windows did not have but this is no longer so. Today, most of the features are either already incorporated within the Windows OS, or can be easily installed with affordable third-party software.
Just take a look at the features that were highlighted in the Mac section:
Both features can be easily found in a third-party software like Adobe PDF or Nuance PDF (which have many more features, such that both Mac and Windows users should probably still buy them).
Same as above. Typically, this is a feature under “Accessibility” for most PDF apps.
Dashboard view is the only feature that Windows does not have. Aside from that, Windows allow you to create multiple desktops, apps expose etc.
Windows 10 also provides some very intuitive features which would be useful for lawyers:
With Windows 10, click Windows + Tab, and you will be able to access the Timeline view. This feature is not available on MacOS.
b. For lawyers, this can be extremely useful if you are trying to access an affidavit that you have been working on, but you cannot locate your file (perhaps you saved in the wrong location). You just need to scroll back in time to find the file.
c. It is also a good way to track what you have been doing, which goes towards billing. If there is a need to prove that you were working on that matter on a particular day, you can easily prove it by using Timeline.
Lawyers have often relied on stenographers in the past. Nowadays, the cost of labour is too high for most law firms to get a stenographer. On Windows, you just need to click “Windows key + H” and you can start dictating on any app. (Note: Before that, if you have not already done so, you might need to setup “Dictation” through settings.)
In terms of security, Windows has also gotten a lot more secure in recent years. If you constantly update your computers (important because security patches/fixes get released all the time), and take note of the general warning signs, you should be safe from viruses or malware. However, if you are still using older versions of Windows, e.g. Windows Vista, you risk being hacked.
The reality of the current consumer market is that it is dominated by MacOS and Windows devices. Other alternative operating systems would be the mobile OS, e.g. iOS or Android. In this regard, iOS would win hands down as Android is not sufficiently developed for a lawyer to use for the day-to-day work.
With the higher portability of iOS devices, document editing can easily be done on an iPad (e.g. Microsoft Office on iOS is quite complete). However, the iOS is not be ideal for most lawyers who need to perform several tasks.
From the above analysis, it would be preferable to use Windows 10. This is the best Windows for lawyers, with features that can compete with MacOS and with better security features.
Due to the competitive Windows market, manufacturers are forced to sell their products at a more competitive price. This means a higher possibility to purchase a workhorse that is cheaper and better customised to the user’s needs, choosing the most ideal from the wide range of PC or laptop models available.